Results of Retrospective Registration Evaluation

This is a list of all the participants and sites who have submitted registrations to us for evaluation. For each site, the first link leads to a set of results tables. A single table contains the results for one modality pair (e.g., registering Computed Tomography (CT) to Magnetic Resonance T1-weighted (T1) is designated "CT_T1"). Each row of the table contains the registration errors for one patient, and each column corresponds to the error as measured at a particular Volume of Interest (VOI). A series of hyphens ("--------") indicates that the VOI for that column was not present in the MR image for the patient corresponding to that row. All errors are expressed in millimeters.

List of participants

Asad Abu-Tarif, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY

            Method 1 — February 10, 2002
            Description of his method

Helmut Alt, Freie Universitat Berlin, Berlin, Germany

            Method 1 — January 27, 2004

            Method 2 — January 27, 2004
            Description of the methods

Lou Arata, Picker International, Highland Heights, OH

            Method 1

John Ashburner, University College, London, UK

          Method 1

            Method 2
            Description of his method

Jamal Atif, X. Ripoche, A. Osorio, LIMSI-CNRS, Orsay, France

          Method 1 —June 23, 2004

          Description of method 1

Christian Barillot and Didier Lemoine, Universite de Rennes, France⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Martin Capek and Ivan Krekule, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague, Czech Republic

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Carlos R. Castro-Pareja and Raj Shekhar,University of Maryland School of Medicine, ML, USA

            Method 1 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 1* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 2 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 2* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 3 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 3* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 4 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 4* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 5 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 5* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 6 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 6* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 7 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 7* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 8 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 8* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 9 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 9* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 10 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 10* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 11 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 11* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 12 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 12* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 13 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 13* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 14 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 14* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 15 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 15* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 16 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 16* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 17 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 17* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 18 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 18* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 19 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 19* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 20 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 20* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 21 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 21* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 22 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 22* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 23 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 23* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 24 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 24* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 25 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 25* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 26 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 26* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 27 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 27* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 28 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 28* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 29 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 29* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 30 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 30* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 31 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 31* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 32 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 32* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 33 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 33* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 34 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 34* — Jan 10, 2005

            Method 35 — Dec 14, 2004

            Method 35* — Jan 10, 2005

          Description of their methods

Hua-mei Chen, Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY

          Method 1

          Method 1*

          Method 1*

          Method 1*

          Method 2

          Method 2*

          Method 2*

          Method 2*

          Method 3

          Method 3*

          Method 3*

          Method 3*
            Description of his methods

Ming Chen, First Medical University, Guangzhou, China

          Method 1 — April 11, 2002

          Method 2 — April 11, 2002

          Method 3 — April 11, 2002

          Method 4 — April 11, 2002

          Method 5 — April 11, 2002

          Method 1 — April 16, 2002

          Method 2 — April 16, 2002

          Method 1* — April 21, 2002

          Method 2* — April 21, 2002

          Method 6 — December 20, 2002

          Method 7 — December 20, 2002
            Description of his method 1
            Description of his method 2
            Description of his method 6
            Description of his method 7

Andre Collignon, Frederik Maes, et al., Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Denis Desseree, Praxim & TIMC Lab, Grenoble Univ., France

          Method 1 — July 2, 2002

          Method 1* — July 9, 2002

          Method 2 — July 9, 2002
            Description of the methods

L. Ding, T. Kularatna, A. Goshtasby, M. Satter, and J. Mantil, Wright State University, Dayton, OH

            Method 1*
            Description of their method

Jon Doll and Louis Arata, Z-kat inc., Ohio, USA

            Method 1 — July 8, 2002

          Method 1 — July 8, 2002

          Method 2 — July 11, 2002

          Method 1 — July 22, 2002

          Method 2 — July 29, 2002

          Method 3 — August 5, 2002

          Method 1b* — September 11, 2002

          Method 2b* — September 11, 2002

          Method 3b* — September 11, 2002
            Description of their methods

Petra van den Elsen, Sandy Napel, et al., Stanford University Medical Center, Stanford, CA⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Yong Fan and Jiang, Tianzi, National Laboratory of Pattern Recognition, Institute of Automation, Beijing, China

            Method 1 — October 27, 2002

            Method 1 — January 26, 2003

            Method 2 — October 8, 2003

            Description of their method 1
            Description of their method 2

M.Feixas, I.Boada, A.Bardera, University of Girona, Grup de Grafics de Girona (GGG)

 

            Method 1 — March 15, 2002

          Method 2 — March 15, 2002

          Method 3 — March 15, 2002

          Method 4 — March 15, 2002

          Method 5 — March 15, 2002

          Method 6 — March 15, 2002

          Method 1* — April 5, 2002

          Method 2* — April 5, 2002

          Method 3* — April 5, 2002

          Method 4* — April 5, 2002

          Method 5* — April 5, 2002

          Method 6* — April 5, 2002

           
            Description of their methods

Soenke Frantz, Karl Rohr, and H. Siegfried Stiehl, University of Hamburg, Germany

          Method 1

          Method 2
          Description of their methods

Rui Gan,Albert C.S. Chung , Department of Computer Science, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong

          Method 1

          Method 2 — May 3, 2005

          Method 3 — May 3, 2005

          Method 4 — May 3, 2005

          Method 5 — May 3, 2005

          Method 6 — May 3, 2005

          Method 7 — May 3, 2005

          Method 8 — May 3, 2005

          Method 9 — May 3, 2005

          Method 10 — May 5, 2005

          Method 11 — May 5, 2005

          Method 2* — May 6, 2005

          Method 3* — May 6, 2005

          Method 4* — May 6, 2005

          Method 5* — May 6, 2005

          Method 6* — May 6, 2005

          Method 7* — May 6, 2005

          Method 8* — May 6, 2005

          Method 9* — May 6, 2005

          Method 10* — May 6, 2005

          Method 11* — May 6, 2005

          Method 2 — May 10, 2005

          Method 5 — May 10, 2005

          Method 12 — May 13, 2005

          Method 13 — May 13, 2005

          Method 14 — May 13, 2005

          Method 15 — May 21, 2005

          Method 16 — May 21, 2005

          Method 22 — August 10, 2005

          Method 23 — August 10, 2005

          Description of their methods

Zhiyong Gao, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, Hubei, China

            Method 1

            Method 2

            Method 3 — February 5, 2002

            Method 4 — February 5, 2002

            Method 5 — February 5, 2002

            Method 6 — February 5, 2002

            Method 7 — March 28, 2002

            Method 8 — April 22, 2002

            Method 9 — April 22, 2002

            Method 10 — April 22, 2002

            Method 11 — April 22, 2002

            Method 12  — April 22, 2002

            Method 13 — June 19, 2002

            Method 13 — June 19, 2002
            Description of the methods 1 to 12
            Description of the method 13

 

Beth Harkness, Bowman Gray School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC⁺

            Method 1
            Description of her method

Renjie He, Ponnada A. Narayana, University of Texas Medical School at HoustonUSA

            Method 1 — July 6, 2004

            Method 1* — July 12, 2004

            Method 1* — July 12, 2004

            Method 1* — July 15, 2004

            Method 1* — July 19, 2004

            Method 1* — July 20, 2004

            Method 1* — July 21, 2004

            Method 1* — August 3, 2004

            Method 1* — August 3, 2004

            Method 1* — August 12, 2004

            Method 1* — August 13, 2004

            Description of the method 1

Paul Hemler, Sandy Napel, et al., Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Derek Hill, Colin Studholme, et al., UMDS Guy's and St. Thomas' Hospitals, London, UK⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Li-yueh Hsu and Murray Loew, George Washington University, Washington, DC

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Henry Huang, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA

            Method 1

Mauro Namias, Roberto A. Isoardi, Escuela de Medicina Nuclear, Mendoza, Argentina

            Method 1 — Nov 29, 2004

            Method 1* — Nov 30, 2004

          Description of their method1

Sarang Joshi, University of North Carolina, North Carolina, USA

            Method 1 — January 22, 2003

          Description of their method
 
Stanislav Kovacic, Peter Rogelj, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovania

            Method 1 — April 11, 2002         
            Description of their method

Yongfang Liang, Hua-mei Chen, The University of Texas at Arlington, Arlington, Texas

          Method 1 - February 3, 2004

          Method 2 - February 3, 2004

          Method 3 - February 3, 2004

          Method 4 - February 3, 2004

          Method 5 - February 3, 2004

          Method 6 - February 3, 2004

          Method 7 - February 3, 2004

          Method 8 - February 3, 2004

          Method 9 - February 3, 2004

          Method 10 - February 3, 2004

          Method 11 - February 3, 2004

          Method 12 - February 3, 2004

          Method 13 - February 3, 2004

          Method 14 - February 3, 2004

          Method 15 - February 3, 2004

          Method 16 - February 3, 2004

          Method 17 - February 3, 2004

          Method 18 - February 3, 2004

          Method 19 - February 3, 2004

          Method 20 - February 3, 2004

          Method 1 - April 12, 2004

          Method 2 - April 12, 2004

          Method 3 - April 12, 2004

          Method 4 - April 12, 2004

          Method 5 - April 12, 2004

          Method 6 - April 12, 2004

          Method 7 - April 12, 2004

          Method 8 - April 12, 2004

          Method 9 - April 12, 2004

          Method 10 - April 12, 2004

          Method 11 - April 12, 2004

          Method 12 - April 12, 2004

          Method 13 - April 12, 2004

          Method 14 - April 12, 2004

          Method 15 - April 12, 2004

          Method 16 - April 12, 2004

          Method 17 - April 12, 2004

          Method 18 - April 12, 2004

          Method 19 - April 12, 2004

          Method 20 - April 12, 2004

          Method 21 - September 27, 2004

          Method 16 - September 27, 2004

          Method 18 - September 27, 2004

          Description of their methods

David Lloret, A. Lopez, and J. Serrat, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona, Spain

          Method 1

          Method 2 *
            Description of their methods

Chi-Hsiang Lo, Yujun Guo, Cheng-Chang Lu, Kent State University, USA

            Method 1 — January 16, 2003

            Method 2 — March 27, 2003

            Method 3 — May 17, 2003

            Description of their method 1

            Description of their method 2

            Description of their method 3

J. B. Antoine Maintz, Petra van den Elsen, and Max Viergever, University Hospital, Utrecht, The Netherlands⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Gregoire Malandain and Xavier Pennec, INRIA, Sophia Antipolis, France⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

George Matsopoulos, N. Mouravliansky, K. Belibasis, and K. Nikita, National Technical University of Athens, Greece

            Method 1
            Description of their method

George Matsopoulos, Evangelia I. Zacharaki, National Technical University of Athens, Greece

            Method 1 — February 26, 2003
            Description of their method

Lydia Ng, Insightful Corp., Seattle, WA

            Method 1 — July 3, 2002
            Description of their method

Christophoros Nikou, F. Heitz, et al., Louis Pasteur University of Strasbourg, France

            Method 1*

          Method 2*
            Description of their methods

Marilyn Noz, Gerald Maguire, et al., New York University Medical Center, New York, NY⁺

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Charles Pelizzari, University of Chicago Hospital, Chicago, IL⁺

            Method 1
            Description of his method

Binjie Qin, Shanghai Jiaotong University, Shanghai, China

          Method 1

          Method 2 — October 8, 2001

          Method 3 — Octobet 13, 2001

          Method 4 — October 13, 2001

          Method 5 — October 13, 2001

          Method 6 — October 13, 2001

          Method 7 — November 29, 2001

          Method 8 — November 29, 2001

          Method 9 — November 29, 2001

          Method 10 — December 9, 2001
            Description of his methods

Jon Beom Ra, Jung Hwi Eun and Yong Sun Kim, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Korea

            Method 1 — October 31, 2002

          Method 1 — January 22, 2003

          Method 2 — January 22, 2003
            Description of their method 1
          Description of their method 2

 

Gene Reddick, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, TN

            Method 1
            Description of his method

HaiPing Ren, Hu Yang, and WenKai Wu, Chinese Acad. of Med. Sci. and Peking Union Med. College, Beijing, China

            Method 1

            Method 2 — April 23, 2001

            Method 3 — September 20, 2001
            Description of their methods 1 and 2

            Description of their method 3

Richard Robb and Dennis Hanson, The Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN⁺

          Method 1

          Method 2

          Method 3

          Method 4
            Description of their methods

Claudia Rodriguez, George Washington University, Washington, DC, USA

          Method 1 — July 3, 2002

          Method 1 — July 9, 2002
            Description of the method

Torsten Rohlfing and J. Beier, Charite, Campus Virchow-Hospital, Berlin, Germany

          Method 1

          Method 2

          Method 3*

          Method 4*

          Method 5*

          Method 6*

            Description of their methods

J. M. Rouet, J. J. Jacq, and C. Roux, ENST Bretagne, France

            Method 1
            Description of their method

Luo Shuqian and Li Xiang, Capital University of Medical Sciences, P. R. China

          Method 1

          Method 2
            Description of their methods

Attila Tanacs, K. Palagyi, and A. Kuba, Jozsef Attila University, Hungary
          Method 1

          Method 2

          Method 3 — October 21, 2002

            Description of their methods

Philippe Thevenaz and Michael Unser, Lausanne Federal Institute of Technology, Switzerland

          Method 1

          Method 2*

          Method 3*
          Method 4 — Jan 29, 2003
          Description of their methods 1, 2 and 3

          Description of their method 4

Dejan Tomazevic, Bostjan Likar and Franos Pernus, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia

          Method 1

          Method 2

          Method 3

          Method 4

          Description of their methods 3 and 4

 
 Roger Woods, UCLA School of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA⁺

          Method 1

          Method 2
            Description of his methods

Bradley Wyman, Insightful Corp., Seattle, WA

            Baseline Method 1 — November 29, 2001

          Convergence Method 2 — November 29, 2001

          Convergence Method 2* — December 7, 2001

          Baseline Method 2 — December 10, 2001

          Convergence Method 1 — January 16, 2002

          Convergence Method 3 — January 16, 2002

          Convergence Method 4  — January 16, 2002
            Description of his methods

Xiaoyan Xu, University of Guelph, Guelph, Canada

          Method 1 —November 2, 2003

          Method 1 —November 7, 2003

          Method 1 —January 28, 2004

          Method 1 —February 5, 2004

          Description of method 1

S.K.Yeung, P.Shi, Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong

          Method 1 —Oct 15, 2004

          Method 2 —Oct 15, 2004

          Method 3 —Oct 15, 2004

          Method 4 —Oct 15, 2004

          Method 5 —Oct 15, 2004

          Method 6 —Oct 15, 2004

          Description of methods

Yang-Ming Zhu, Philips Medical Systems, Ohio, USA

          Method 1 — June 27, 2002

          Method 1 — July 2, 2002

          Method 2 — July 8, 2002

          Method 3 — July 8, 2002
          Description of method 1
          Description of the methods 2 and 3


(* indicates that the results were submitted after accuracy evaluations for previous method(s) had been provided to that group).

(⁺ indicates that they were the first set of people submitting their registration results)

 

 Return to previous page